Waiter Peninsula Reviews
Reviews of Musical Events on the Monterey Peninsula
Lyn Bronson, Editor
P.O. Box 1801
Carmel, CA 93921
Phone: (831) 624-7971
Fax: (831) 625-3717
E-mail: LBronson@redshift.com

http://www.BronsonPianoStudio.com/reviews.htm


Date Review Organization
03/08/03 Pianist Van Cliburn California State University Stanislaus

Van Cliburn

by

Lyn Bronson

In the classical music world, pianist Van Cliburn is a living legend. He is an icon bearing witness to a significant event that occurred during the height of the cold war at the time the Soviet Union was reaping an enormous propaganda victory from the launch of its ground-breaking satellite, Sputnik. Van Cliburn, a young Juilliard graduate, age 23 from Kilgore, Texas, (a town most people had never heard of before) went to Moscow in 1958 to compete in an international piano competition whose outcome was rigged in favor of Soviet and Warsaw block participants and won the gold medal. He became an instant cold war hero who restored American prestige internationally, and his victory proved to the world that one of our young musicians, nurtured in a privately funded institution of higher learning could hold his own in competition with hothouse-grown, state-supported Soviet musicians.  

After his victory, Van Cliburn toured extensively and made new fans everywhere. His recordings made shortly after his win in Moscow sold millions of copies and are still available today. However, in the 1970s Van Cliburn began to retire from the concert stage, which was quite understandable in the light of the over bookings in the early years of his enormous popular success. He simply had committed himself to too many performances and needed a rest. 

In his retirement he entered a new phase of his life in which he wanted to encourage young musicians. First we saw in his new hometown of Ft. Worth, the establishment of the Van Cliburn Foundation, and shortly thereafter, the Van Cliburn International Piano Competition, which in a few short years became one of the most important piano competitions in the world. 

Van Cliburn in recent years has occasionally been coming out of retirement to make guest appearances for charities, or even more rarely, give a public concert to benefit some worthy cause. And this week he came to California’s central valley, to California State University Stanislaus, to play a benefit piano recital at the official opening of the new Bernell and Flora Snider Music Recital Hall. Just how unusual this occasion was can be gauged by the audience and media reaction to this event. This was a gala affair, and it attracted a lot of attention and support from the community. 

Last night, Saturday, March 8, was the big event, and after a pre-concert reception, the capacity audience filed in to fill the 312 seat hall and wait in eager anticipation of hearing Mr. Cliburn. The evening began with introductory remarks by Dr. Marvalene Hughes, President of California State University Stanislaus, who graciously gave kudos to Mr. & Mrs. Snider and all the other special people who had made it possible for the recital hall’s construction and the bringing of Van Cliburn to Turlock.

When Mr. Cliburn walked out on stage he received a tumultuous acclaim. Elegant does not do justice to describe his appearance. We all know that he is six feet four inches tall, but as he stepped out into the limelight, he looked more like seven feet tall, and never did anyone looked more impressive in a set of concert full dress tails. 

When he finally sat down to play, the first thing we heard was Van Cliburn’s own arrangement of “The Star Spangled Banner.” It was a magnificently stirring performance, with the audience standing in rapt attention. Then, we heard a program of many of his old favorites  six selections by Brahms, a Debussy group and after intermission three Chopin selections. 

How do you describe his playing? Well, it was larger than life and not for the faint of heart. While it was big, bold, and authoritative, effects were often exaggerated, so that soft dynamics were loud, and loud dynamics were louder, with the overall impression being of extremely percussive pounding (the piano needed and received retuning during the intermission). But, always it was clear that Van Cliburn was in command of enormous technical and expressive resources, so that whether it conformed or not to your own personal tastes, by any standard, this was totally masterful playing. 

At the end of the program, the three Chopin selections made the most moving impression during the evening. The large scaled performance of the popular “Military” Polonaise had a proper majesty about it, the Ballade in F Minor had many lovely moments, and the Scherzo in C-sharp Minor really blew us away. During the chorale section of the Scherzo, the descending broken chord patterns achieved a shimmering, magical quality that one rarely ever hears in the concert hall today. 

After the final applause, Van Cliburn moved to the edge of the stage and addressed the audience. This was an opportunity for everyone in the audience to hear him speak and observe how gracious and gentlemanly he can be in acknowledging the wonderful efforts of the community and the University in making it possible for this new recital hall to be built. His second encore (the first was the Rachmaninoff Prelude in G# Minor, Op. 32, No. 12) was Schumann’s Widmung, (Dedication), which he played to honor the commitment and dedication of this great community effort. 

Mr. Cliburn received a long and grateful standing ovation.

 
End

Back to Reviews
HOME