Waiter Peninsula Reviews
Reviews of Musical Events on the Monterey Peninsula
Lyn Bronson, Editor
P.O. Box 1801
Carmel, CA 93921
Phone: (831) 624-7971
Fax: (831) 625-3717
E-mail: LBronson@redshift.com

http://www.BronsonPianoStudio.com/reviews.htm


Date Review Organization
07/16/04 Noriko Ogawa Piano Master Class Piano Festival Northwest

Noriko Ogawa Piano Master Class

by

Lyn Bronson

After a triumphant recital the night before in Miller Hall at Portland’s World Forestry Center under the auspices of Piano Festival Northwest, Noriko Ogawa appeared bright eyed and alert on stage the next morning for a master class. In some master classes, too many students are scheduled resulting in each student only receiving a minimal amount of time so that details are worked out only superficially. This has not been the case with master classes at the Piano Festival Northwest since the sessions are 90 minutes long and only two or three students participate in each session.

The first student up at bat was Hunter Noack, who has just completed the ninth grade at Interlochen Arts Academy, where he studies piano with Steve Perry. Hunter has performed in the Sunriver Music Festival Young Artist Scholarship concerts in 2001, 2002, 2003, and 2004. In the printed program he was scheduled to perform Liszt’s Transcendental Etude No. 4, Mazeppa. Walking out on stage cold and playing Mazeppa is a daunting task, so Hunter decided to perform for the class Chopin’s Fantasie-Impromptu instead.  His fleet fingers delivered a smoothly flowing, yet nicely agitated performance. Especially charming was the D-flat major middle section, which was tender and lovingly shaped.

Ms. Ogawa complimented him on a very sensitive performance that was very clean and very musical. She pointed out that the initial octave G# in the left hand that introduces the piece wasn’t powerful enough and didn’t fill the two measures it was supposed to fill, and thus sounded more like a quarter note rather than two whole notes tied. She also suggested that after the arpeggiated bass pattern began in the left hand, that he had to let it diminish so that the audience could hear the right hand when it entered.

Ms. Ogawa worked with Hunter to aim for the focal points of important phrases and also to adopt a faster, more flowing tempo in the Moderato cantabile D-flat major middle section and this helped to produce longer lines in the melody. Hunter was receptive to her suggestions and proved to be not only a sensitive young musician, but also very adaptable and cooperative.

The second performer at this session was Russian born Tatyana Doroshkin, who has just completed her undergraduate studies at Portland State University, studying with Harold Gray. She won the PSU Concerto Competition both in 2002 and in 2003.

After she performed Ravel’s Toccata from Le Tombeau de Couperin, Ms. Ogawa complimented her on her courage in coming out cold and playing this work which is difficult to perform even when it is played as the final work of the suite. Ms Ogawa noted that Ravel’s score is precisely marked with performance indications. However this does not include pedal markings, and thus one of the first things they worked on together was removing some pedaling that was obscuring the clarity of the repeated note passages.

Ms. Ogawa suggested that the tempo in this work should be pretty consistent in order to maintain the forward motion, however in those passages where there are eruptions of fortissimo, the performer needs to take more time to ensure clarity. She also commented on the “nightmarish” passages where the hands are seemingly right on top of each other.

Ms Doroshkin was advised to use the soft pedal only as a last resort for it can have a tendency to dull the sound and obscure clarity. With remarkable candor, Ms. Ogawa confessed that there are a few passages in this work which are terrifyingly difficult and “cause her heart to beat faster” because they can go terribly wrong.

By the end of this session, we were observing Ms. Doroshkin’s performance improve dramatically so that we were hearing a most remarkable performance.

 
End

Back to Reviews
HOME